English   |    French

  Friday PM

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

Ambassador Amina Mohammed / 02 February 2017

Kwamchetsi Makokha

 

Genuine surprise has greeted news out of Addis Ababa that Kenya’s foreign minister will not occupy the chair of the African Union Commission as the continent’s foremost diplomat.

Only last November, Ms Vestine Nahimana, the Burundian ambassador to The Hague, Netherlands, was distributing Ms Amina Mohammed’s campaign materials to diplomats at the World Forum, venue of last year’s Assembly of States Parties. Burundi had just served notice of intent to withdraw from the International Criminal Court after South Africa, and quickly followed by the Gambia.

 “We have a good candidate,” Ms Nahimana enthused in Kiswahili since her French and my English constantly clashed. Burundi’s failure to support the Kenya candidacy in Addis was a curious highlight of the election.

The ASP is a wasteland in the wake of Ms Mohammed’s scorched earth diplomacy on behalf of Kenya’s efforts to extricate its President and Deputy President from charges at the ICC. It is also a living reminder of Kenya’s and Ms Mohammed’s bellicosity.

Ms Mohammed’s candidacy had seemed like a slam dunk. Her intelligence, eloquence, experience and personal charm recommended her greatly. She was just what the doctor ordered after the initial slate of former Ugandan Vice President Specioza Wandira Kazibwe and Botswana’s Dr Pelonomi Venson-Moitoi, and Equatorial Guinea’s Agapito Mba Mokuy failed to command two-thirds of the continent’s 54 votes.

At the AU, Kenya has shaped relations between the ICC and the continental body, thanks in no small part to Ms Mohammed’s leadership as Cabinet Secretary for foreign affairs. Within months of assuming office, she had mobilized the AU for an extraordinary summit at which President Kenyatta lambasted the ICC for race baiting and dismissed it as a tool of declining imperial powers. Subsequently, the AU was forced to adopt a posture of grave injury towards the ICC, even establishing an open-ended ministerial committee to strategise on mass withdrawal from the court.

So poisoned were relations that efforts at formal contact through the establishment of an ICC liaison office at the AU were permanently rebuffed during the tenure of outgoing chair Nkosazana-Dlamini Zuma.

Last week, at Leiden University in the Netherlands, a leaked confidential AU strategy on mass withdrawal from the ICC was presented outlining legal, political and institutional steps to be undertaken. “The collectiveness of the action [mass withdrawal] has the potential to radically reconfigure existing forms of international cooperation,” the document says in part. AU strategists figure that withdrawal from a treaty "can give a denouncing state additional voice, either by increasing its leverage to reshape the treaty to more accurately reflect its interests or those of its domestic constituencies, or by establishing a rival legal norm or institution together with other like-minded states.”

Although President Kenyatta enjoys great personal influence in Addis Ababa, it was not enough to deliver the AU chair. Addis is the only capital where the agreeable Ms Catherine Muigai is ambassador. She is not just a diplomat waiting in line to speak to the President through the Africa desk at the Ministry Foreign Affairs but can call to chat about his children -- her nieces and nephews. A diplomat with that kind of access has great influence in a capital like Addis, which not only headquarters the AU but also the United Nations Economic Commission for Africa. Mr Kenyatta is also a beneficiary of hereditary diplomacy. His father, Kenya’s first president, established personal friendships across the continent that the son continues to benefit from. But as early as last year’s summit, African diplomats were beginning to avoid their Kenyan counterparts in Addis because of a widespread belief that Nairobi had already obtained all that it could from the AU. While Kenya’s aggressive diplomacy may have delivered results, it has also engendered bitterness in countries that feel that the East African nation was getting too big for its breeches.

 

At the ICC, Amina’s candidacy was not accepted as an inescapable inevitability, given what initiatives she led had bred.

Over a dinner of lamb stew and rice at an African diplomat’s house in The Hague last year, I heard for the first time how countries on the continent were working to stop her coronation. Senegal, especially, was working on a strategy that would distance critical West African and Francophone states from offering her support.

Notably, Nigeria and Senegal issued statements distancing themselves from the ICC withdrawal statement a week before this year’s summit. Ms Mohammed, the poster child of that campaign, was never going to enjoy the support of West Africa, and especially the Francophone countries. When the numbers were in, it was clear that she was never going to garner the requisite two-thirds of the vote.

 

< >

Other Headlines


There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

Ntaganda takes the stand in his own defence at the ICC

BY Susan Kendi / ON 23 June 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

Burundi : Persistence of serious human rights violations in a climate of widespread fear

BY Susan Kendi / ON 20 June 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

President Uhuru Kenyatta urged to act on the rise of uninvestigated extra-judicial killings

BY Susan Kendi / ON 20 June 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

Acholi chief reveals his role in peace talks efforts between LRA and Museveni

BY Susan Kendi / ON 16 June 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

Affaire Ntaganda : La Chambre d’appel de la CPI confirme la compétence de la Cour pour connaître de deux chefs de crimes de guerre

BY Journalists for Justice / ON 15 June 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

Le Procureur de la CPI demande que les suspects, Messieurs Saïf Al-Islam Qadhafi et Al-Tuhamy Mohamed Khaled,soient immédiatement arrêtés et remis à la Cour

BY Journalists for Justice / ON 15 June 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

Bensouda: Olive branch of peace is barren without the trunk of blind justice

BY Journalists for Justice / ON 13 June 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

Ntaganda defense off to a rocky start as lawyers reel Rwanda, Uganda into trial

BY Susan Kendi / ON 13 June 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

How LRA fighters lived with and fought alongside South Sudanese soldiers

BY Journalists for Justice / ON 23 May 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

Ongwen still my boss, my friend and my brother – witness tells court

BY Journalists for Justice / ON 11 May 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

Thousands of post-election violence rapists went scot-free in Kenya

BY Editor / ON 02 May 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

How victims brought a cruel dictator to justice

BY Journalists for Justice / ON 02 May 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

Judge Trendafilova heads new international court as it holds first public session

BY Journalists for Justice / ON 12 May 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

New challenges for ICC on the horizon from the North as African threats to withdraw recede

BY Journalists for Justice / ON 22 March 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

How attack on Pajule IDP camp was planned, by ICC witness

BY Journalists for Justice / ON 13 March 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

Fear and loathing at Dominic Ongwen’s ICC trial

BY A map of the Barlonyo massacre / ON 08 March 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

South Africa revokes notice to withdraw from the ICC

BY Journalists for Justice / ON 09 March 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

You failed us on truth report, violence victims tell Uhuru Kenyatta

BY Journalists for Justice / ON 01 March 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

Revealed: How prosecutors fought to protect witnesses in Kenyatta case

BY JFJustice / ON 07 April 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

BY Ambassador Amina Mohammed / ON 02 February 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

Bensouda challenges UN security council to end impasse on Darfur

BY Journalists for Justice / ON 09 January 2017

There is no way Kenya was going to take the AU chair

BY Journalists for Justice / ON 12 August 2016

JOIN US