Resources
Friday, May 27, 2022
  • Login
Journalists for Justice
No Result
View All Result

Browse by Topic:

  • Home
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Human Rights
  • Elections
  • About US
  • Our Work
  • Careers
No Result
View All Result
Journalists for Justice
  • Home
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Human Rights
  • Elections
  • About US
  • Our Work
  • Careers
No Result
View All Result
Journalists for Justice
No Result
View All Result
Home SGBV

Call-it-what-it-is: Breaking the taboo around sexual violence

Journalists For JusticebyJournalists For Justice
July 5, 2019
in SGBV
Reading Time: 8 mins read
A A
0
Race to succeed Bensouda begins as clock ticks to her exit
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Taboos around sexual violence have created silences around its various manifestations. A Hague-based organization, Women’s Initiative for Gender Justice (WIJG) has come up with an ambitious campaign ‘Call It What It Is’ to help shape contemporary and victim-centric guidance to (international) criminal law practitioners on what makes violence “sexual”. Alix Vuillemin Grendel, Senior Advocacy Adviser for WIGJ recently spoke to Joyce J. Wangui on the importance of this campaign and how it will impact the legal framework on sexual violence at the ICC. The two met during a symposium in Kampala “Sexual Violence: Advancing the Agenda?” organized by the Refugee Law Project, which among other things, delved into the language gaps found in criminal law in addition to discussing the diversity of forms of sexual violence not captured by law.

What prompted your campaign and how will it help in advancing the sexual violence agenda of both response and prevention?

Our campaign was prompted by the recognition that there is a gap in the ICC’s legal texts. While the Rome Statute is the first international criminal law instrument to expressly include crimes of sexual violence, it does not sufficiently define the term “sexual violence” nor does it provide examples of acts, which might be captured by the crime of “any other form of sexual violence of comparable gravity.”

Could you be more specific?

To be more specific on the legal gap, there are six crimes listed in the Rome Statute categorized as sexual violence: Rape, sexual slavery, enforced prostitution, forced pregnancy, enforced sterilization and ‘ any other form of sexual violence of comparable gravity’ both as war crimes and crimes against humanity. (Also, sexual violence can also be a constitutive act of genocide).

RelatedStories

For Jammeh, sexual violence was a weapon of repression and torture

Victory for human rights as Tanzania allows young mothers back in school

Covid-19 unleashed shadow pandemic of gender-based violence UN Women says

To understand what those six crimes can be, one must turn to the ICC Elements of Crimes. Indeed, the ICC Elements of Crimes are to assist the Court in the interpretation and application of the Rome Statute articles on crimes against humanity, war crimes and genocide. The Elements of Crime define what constitutes an act of rape, forced pregnancy, and enforced sterilisation.

With regard to the crimes of sexual slavery, enforced prostitution, forced pregnancy, enforced sterilisation, or any other form of sexual violence of comparable gravity, the only guide given by the Elements is that an “act of a sexual nature” must have been committed. However, it does not provide examples or guidance as to what could constitute an “act of a sexual nature”.

This lack of guidance in the ICC legal texts highlights: A lack of clarity about what makes violence sexual; and a disparity between how sexual violence is – and will be – deliberated in courts and how the violence is perceived and experienced by victims.

What sort of agenda is your campaign pushing?

We started our Call it what it is Campaign, and decided to call on the collective strength of civil society to give survivors of sexual violence in conflict a voice in shaping a contemporary, victim-centric and contextually relevant guidance, through a Civil Society Declaration, to international and national criminal law practitioners on what makes violence “sexual”. This Declaration aims to be a tool in domestic and international institutions in order to better understand what is an act of sexual violence to the survivors.

If I can cite an example, in 2010, prosecutors at the ICC filed charges against Kenyan president Uhuru Kenyatta which included forcible circumcisions under the category of “other forms of sexual violence but judges decided to classify those crimes as ‘other inhumane acts’. Why this shift?

In the decision on the confirmation of charges in the Kenyatta et al. case, ICC judges decided to classify those crimes as ‘other inhumane acts’. They rejected the argument that forced circumcision of men constitutes sexual violence, stating: “The Chamber is of the view that not every act of violence which targets parts of the body commonly associated with sexuality should be considered an act of sexual violence.” Rather, the Chamber found that “it appears from the evidence that the acts were motivated by ethnic prejudice and intended to demonstrate cultural superiority of one tribe over the other” and were thus better characterized as “other inhumane acts.” (ICC-01/09-02/11-382-Red, paras 265-266.) However, if violence against a person’s sexual organs is not necessarily a crime of sexual violence, then what is?

Sexual violence suffers from an alarming lack of precision largely due to the language used by practitioners-humanitarians, academics, service providers, activists and journalists like myself – language which does not call it what it is…In your campaign, what sort of language have you identified as faulty and how will it [campaign] rectify this?

What we identified most is that there was a gap – so no language at all to define what constitutes an act of sexual nature, or what may constitute the term ‘ sexual’, especially to survivors of these acts. There is no universal view of what makes an act ‘ sexual’ – this is largely dependent on the individual, on the context of the act, on the culture in which the act occurs…

Why is it important to ‘call it what it is’?

It is crucial to ‘call it what it is’ to ensure a better reflection of the harm suffered by victims/survivors of sexual violence in conflict at all stages of international, regional and national criminal law procedures. Only then can we work toward full accountability as part of a process of meaningful justice.

What is the one thing you took from the symposium which you were not aware of?

Difficult to answer, as there were so many things I took away from the symposium!

But focusing on the input I was seeking for the Civil Society Declaration on sexual violence – that seeks to inform practitioners by giving guidance on what an act of sexual violence could constitute to a survivor plus giving a list of examples of acts of a sexual nature – I learned that the Declaration should explicitly include (along the many other acts we have already listed) acts of tying, burning, electrocuting and crushing of genital organs.

As you go around speaking to survivors, what are some of the different or new forms of sexual violence that they articulate; perhaps away from the predominant forms attached to the genital area?

Indeed. From the consultations with self-identified survivors of sexual violence, we learned that in certain contexts, the wrists, the hair, and the lower back (for example) are body parts that survivors have identified as being ‘sexual’. From one group of survivors, we understood that they experience the act of being ‘marked’ by having been bitten (bites that leave visible scars) following rape, is in itself also an act of sexual violence. From another group of survivors, the fear or reasonable apprehension of sexual violence – without explicit threat or physical acts – constitutes sexual violence in itself. 

Is your campaign looking at sexual violence against men and boys in conflict? As regards language, you often hear many male survivors describing their experiences as  “sexual torture”.

Yes, we do very much include sexual violence against men and boys. We will need help however in making sure that we cover as much as possible and that it is as inclusive as can be. If survivors want to call their lived experiences “sexual torture”, it should be up to them. There are limits in terminologies used in law, but mere accountability doesn’t necessarily make for meaningful justice, not to all survivors at least.

We are also looking to have more consultations with survivors, including in Syria in June.

As you collect data for your campaign, what are some of the assumptions, misconceptions of sexual violence that you have come across (from academics, lawyers, researchers, survivors, humanitarians) and how do they impede on response to conflict related sexual violence?

What we learned, or what was confirmed to us, is that an act of a sexual nature may be sexual in nature (to the victim/survivor or to the perpetrator) even if there is no sexual gratification. Similarly, there is no need for physical contact for an act to be sexual in nature to the victim/survivor or to the perpetrator. For example, an act may be experienced as being sexual if it affects a person’s sexual orientation or gender identity. Again, the whether an act is sexual in nature and whether it is experienced as violence is partly based in cultural context. One must understand this context in order to understand whether sexual violence has been committed, and thus whether it must be investigated, prosecuted etc. as such.

The list of what may constitute acts of sexual nature is long, as is the list of examples of ‘ acts of sexual nature ‘ – both will be included in the Civil Society declaration.

Lastly, how can the law incorporate the new understanding and definitions of sexual violence to advance accountability for this crime?

With the Civil Society Declaration, we seek to offer a contemporary, victim-centric and contextually relevant guidance, or reference point, to criminal law practitioners on what makes violence sexual. This, again, would ultimately help to ensure a better reflection of the harm suffered by victims of sexual violence in conflict at all stages of criminal law procedures. While not the primary aim of the campaign, the Civil Society Declaration could lead to clarifying the definition of sexual violence at the ICC and in other relevant legal texts. We however do not seek to define sexual violence, as definitions inherently give a narrower framework than the many forms and ways sexual violence can be perpetrated or experienced.

—

Previous Post

Ongwen did not take part in Pajule attack, defence witness tells court

Next Post

Congo warlord guilty of crimes against humanity

Journalists For Justice

Journalists For Justice

Related Posts

Former beauty pageant winner Fatou Jallow aka Toufa. The TRRC recommends that former president Yahya Jammeh should be procusecuted for raping her. Photo credit: Jason Florio and Helen Florio from Gambia- Victims and Resisters.

For Jammeh, sexual violence was a weapon of repression and torture

February 16, 2022
Tanzania former President John Pombe Magufuli. Photo: Charles Onyango- Obbo Twitter

Victory for human rights as Tanzania allows young mothers back in school

December 15, 2021
16 Days of Activism against Gender-based Violence. Illustration: UN Women

Covid-19 unleashed shadow pandemic of gender-based violence UN Women says

November 25, 2021
Calls for reparation dominate debate at day for sexual violence survivors

Calls for reparation dominate debate at day for sexual violence survivors

June 24, 2021
Kenyan judge awards SGBV survivors millions of shillings in general damages

Kenyan judge awards SGBV survivors millions of shillings in general damages

December 10, 2020
Survivors of sexual violence that occured after the December 2007 presidential election gather at the Milimani Law Courts in Nairobi, Kenya during a hearing into a constitutional petiton they filed. The High Court is scheduled to deliver a judgment on that petition on Thursday, December 10, 2020. Credit: Physicians for Human Rights (PHR).

Kenyan SGBV victims wait with bated breath for Thursday’s judgment

December 8, 2020
Next Post
Race to succeed Bensouda begins as clock ticks to her exit

Congo warlord guilty of crimes against humanity

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Login
Notify of
Please login to comment
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
No Result
View All Result

Recent Posts

  • Said Abdel Kani to remain in custody as Appeals Chamber rejects his plea for release
  • Are we ready? CSOs audit Kenya’s election preparedness
  • Parties prepare to wind up Gicheru case
  • Hope at last for Kenyan victims, but is TFV’s planned support enough?
  • Gicheru asks ICC judge to admit new evidence

Recent Comments

  • JFJ - Journalists for Justice on Kenyan lawyer denies bribery charges at the ICC
  • JFJ - Journalists for Justice on You did me wrong, Bemba tells ICC as he demands 70 million euros
  • JFJ - Journalists for Justice on Two victims’ lawyers in Kenyatta case in line to become next ICC prosecutor
  • JFJ - Journalists for Justice on Profiles of the four people shortlisted for the job of ICC Prosecutor
  • Write My Essay on Afghanistan case fails to take off at the ICC — pragmatism’ or surrender to the powerful?

Archives

Categories

JFJ – Journalists for Justice

We call out impunity wherever it occurs; we advocate justice for all victims of atrocity crimes; and we work with people of goodwill everywhere who share our values.

Browse by Topics:

Archives by Month:

Never Again
INTAHE
BarometreVerite
The Victims' Bantaba
No Result
View All Result
  • Confronting Impunity
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion
  • About US
  • Our Work
  • Login

Copyright © 2019. Journalists for Justice has asserted its right to be recognized as creators and owners of the content here. Reproduction in part or in whole is permitted on condition that JFJ is acknowledged and notified.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
wpDiscuz