• About US
  • Our Work
Saturday, June 10, 2023
  • Login
JFJ - Journalists for Justice
  • Home
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Human Rights
  • Elections
  • About US
  • Our Work
  • Careers
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Human Rights
  • Elections
  • About US
  • Our Work
  • Careers
No Result
View All Result
JFJ - Journalists for Justice
No Result
View All Result

Secret ICC indictments can hamper defence work

byJournalists For Justice
September 13, 2019
in ICC Cases
Reading Time: 3 mins read
71
A A
Alfred Yekatom

On 23 November 2018, Alfred Yekatom appeared before Pre-Trial Chamber II of the International Criminal Court (“ICC” or “Court”), at the seat of the ICC in The Hague (The Netherlands). Pictured here: Mr Yekatom during his initial appearance before the ICC on 23 November 2018 ©ICC-CPI

23
SHARES
255
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on Whatsapp

By Thomas Verfuss in The Hague

Sealed indictments by international courts – or “secret indictments” as press and public often call them – can hamper the work of defence teams and thus jeopardize the right of a suspect to a fair trial. This is stated by the defence team of Alfred Yékatom, the first war crimes suspect from the Central African Republic who came into the custody of the International Criminal Court, in 2018.

It can be concluded from circumstances that there must be other CAR suspects wanted by the ICC than Yékatom and his co-detainee in The Hague, Patrice-Edouard Ngaïssona, who was arrested later in 2018. Potential Central African witnesses for the Yékatom defence don’t want to talk to the lawyers for fear of incriminating themselves, in case they are subject to a “secret arrest warrant” too and might end up one day in The Hague.
The defence team writes in a submission to the judges: “On the other hand, the defence is prejudiced by maintaining the identities of the co-suspects under seal because persons who the Defence have sought to interview in preparation of the confirmation hearing have been reluctant to cooperate, speculating that they are the ones named in the arrest warrant. These persons do not want to prejudice their own “case” by providing an interview to the defence.”

The sealed indictments were invented at the International Criminal Tribunal for the Former Yugoslavia, the first contemporaneous international criminal court and thus the predecessor of the ICC, by Louise Arbour, who was chief prosecutor of the ICTY from 1996 till 1999. The ICTY was then in a situation similar to the ICC now: there were many outstanding arrest warrants, partly against high-level suspects, but there had not been arrests for quite some time. So there was little trial activity, as at the ICC now: the Ongwen trial, the only one ongoing, will be over in a couple of months, and if they charges against Yékatom and Ngaïssona and Malian suspect Al Hassan are not confirmed, in the foreseeable future, there will be no trial activity left.

RelatedPosts

Former Séléka militia leader pleads not guilty as trial begins

Court lays the groundwork for closing phase in Al Hassan case

Al Hassan trial resumes after break

So Arbour resorted to the sealed indictments to facilitate and encourage arrests. UN troops that were present in various parts of the former Yugoslavia, could use the element of surprise when executing the arrest warrants. This led to a new series of arrests soon.

This course of events shows, by the way, why the “popular” expression secret arrest warrant is not precise. “They are not put into a drawer because that would make no sense”, the then ICTY spokesman said. They are just sealed from the public’s (and the suspect’s) eyes, but shared with relevant actors like states and international organisations that can help execute the arrest warrants.

This way sealed arrest warrants can help the functioning of international courts, but also jeopardise the principle of fair trials, one of the cornerstones of (international) courts, as the Yékatom defence now alleges. According to Peter Robinson, co-counsel for Yékatom, it is the first time this point is raised by a defence team – at least to this knowledge, the US lawyer said in response to a question by JFJ.

Yékatom and Ngaïssona are the first suspects from the CAR in custody of the ICC. Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda wants them to stand trial for crimes against humanity and war crimes like murder, torture, mutilation, deportation, pillaging, enrollment of child soldiers and attacks on humanitarian missions during the bloody sectarian violence in 2013 and 2014. The hearings on the confirmation of charges are due to start on September 19.

Related

Share9Tweet6Send
Previous Post

The Dominic Ongwen trial to resume after Easter break

Next Post

Two witnesses testify about LRA attacks in Teso

Next Post
ICC Outreach: Opening of ICC Ongwen trial broadcasted in Kampala Uganda

Two witnesses testify about LRA attacks in Teso

Please login to join discussion

Recent Posts

  • ICJ to hold hearings on Ukraine and Russia conflict
  • The greatness of small: A story of strategic political advocacy
  • Swiss court charges Gambian ex-minister Ousman Sonko with crimes against humanity
  • Ben Ferencz, a legend of international justice
  • Old challenges, new point of view: New Registrar’s vision for the ICC

Follow us on Twitter

JFJ – Journalists for Justice

We call out impunity wherever it occurs; we advocate justice for all victims of atrocity crimes; and we work with people of goodwill everywhere who share our values.

Subscribe to our Newsletter


Loading

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Human Rights
  • Elections
  • About US
  • Our Work
  • Careers

Copyright © 2019. Journalists for Justice has asserted its right to be recognized as creators and owners of the content here. Reproduction in part or in whole is permitted on condition that JFJ is acknowledged and notified.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.