Resources
Wednesday, May 18, 2022
  • Login
Journalists for Justice
No Result
View All Result

Browse by Topic:

  • Home
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Human Rights
  • Elections
  • About US
  • Our Work
  • Careers
No Result
View All Result
Journalists for Justice
  • Home
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Human Rights
  • Elections
  • About US
  • Our Work
  • Careers
No Result
View All Result
Journalists for Justice
No Result
View All Result
Home Commentary

Why South Africa is not quitting from the ICC yet

Journalists for JusticebyJournalists for Justice
October 3, 2015
in Commentary
Reading Time: 5 mins read
A A
0
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

 South Africa is not about to withdraw from the International Criminal Court (ICC), despite the ANC resolving at a conference earlier this month that the government should do exactly that.

The Mail & Guardian has learned that a difference of opinion in the government has stalled the matter and that it is reluctant to implement the party’s resolution.

This is the strongest signal yet that withdrawing from the ICC is not universally supported in the ANC and among its deployees in government, despite the fact that party leaders have claimed unity on the matter.

South Africa has been at odds with the international court since June, when Sudanese President Omar al-Bashir visited the country to attend an African Union summit. As a signatory to the ICC’s Rome Statute, Pretoria was expected to arrest al-Bashir – indicted for war crimes, crimes against humanity and genocide – but President Jacob Zuma’s government allowed him to leave the country despite a court order specifically prohibiting his departure.

A senior government official in the diplomatic corps told the M&G that the stark differences in how to handle the country’s proposed withdrawal from the ICC are mainly between those in government who understood the possible negative impact of that action and politicians who simply wanted to take the hard line to make a point.

RelatedStories

Despite challenges, ICC has affirmed role of law and norms in the international system

Fatou Bensouda: The challenges and the record

The highs and lows of ICC Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda’s tenure

“We regrouped as diplomats and said: ‘Yes, we want to consider and respect the movement’s resolutions, but there are issues that we need to consider first,’” the government source said.

“We [South Africa] are the leader on the continent and we are the ones who stopped African countries from withdrawing from the ICC. We can’t engage on that matter before we make the necessary consultations with other African countries.”

The source was referring to the African Union summit in 2013, where South Africa convinced fellow countries on the continent that it was a bad idea to leave the ICC. At the time, the ANC had asked the South African delegation “not to break ranks with the continent”, whose members were almost unanimous in their wish to withdraw from the Netherlands-based court.

The same source stressed that there won’t be “any movement on this any time soon. In fact, expect the government position to say after looking at the NGC [national general council] resolution and reviewing our participation in the ICC: ‘We don’t think it’s a good idea to pull out of the ICC at the moment.’”

A second diplomatic source told the M&G that international relations officials are not convinced by the reasons behind the ANC’s resolution. This second source said South Africa’s withdrawal from the ICC would, if it happens, affect the country’s efforts to transform the United Nations Security Council. The source said while the Security Council cannot impose sanctions on Pretoria because of noncooperation with the ICC, withdrawing from the court would affect the country’s international status.

The first government source said that even if pressure was exerted on government to withdraw from the ICC, starting the process “won’t happen in the next three years. If you’re expecting a mass exodus from the ICC because South Africa is pulling out, don’t hold your breath.”

A technicality in the ANC’s resolution could be used to work around the matter, the source said. “The narrative in government is that the NGC did not say pull out. It said: ‘Review your participation in the ICC.’ Our role as diplomats is to remain sober instead of being influenced by political emotions. These are people who’ll say: ‘Break ties with the West and go with China,’ without thinking about the implications. Europe is still our strategic trade partner.”

Another diplomat said that for now, officials are telling their global counterparts that withdrawing from the ICC is merely a party decision and not the official government position.

The government position lends credence to information shared by M&G sources that al-Bashir will not return to South Africa for the Forum on China-Africa Co-operation summit in December, despite earlier indications that he would. The Sudanese delegation would instead be led by one of that country’s Cabinet ministers.

“South Africa will not take a risk of inviting al-Bashir here again after what happened,” the first government source said. “Do you think he also wants to go through all that [being sneaked out of the country for fear of arrest] again?”

International affairs spokesperson Nelson Kgwete referred questions to the ANC because, he said, it was the party that had mentioned withdrawing from the ICC.

ANC spokesperson Keith Khoza said the party’s resolution said the country should pull out of the ICC as a “last resort”.

“The position of the ANC was that the government must engage other governments within the African Union, so that it’s an AU matter. They must explore other means of addressing what has been identified as problems,” he said. “If that fails then they must withdraw, so withdrawing is the last resort.”

But ANC national executive committee member Obed Bapela, speaking on behalf of the international relations commission at the NGC, firmly stated that the ANC wants South Africa to start the process of leaving the international court.

Bapela’s position is supported by the resolutions published on the ANC website, which say that “the NGC took the decision to ask the ANC-led government to begin the process of withdrawal of its membership of the ICC, preceded by the discussions that are taking place among the member states of the ICC and those taking place within the African Union on the ICC matter”.

Read more

Previous Post

Reject Kenya and South Africa’s proposed agenda items urges Amnesty International

Next Post

Kenya and South Africa propose supplementary agenda items for inclusion at the 14 ASP

Journalists for Justice

Journalists for Justice

Related Posts

Former ICC Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda. Photo: © Ilvy Njiokiktjien / VII

Despite challenges, ICC has affirmed role of law and norms in the international system

August 8, 2021
From left to right: the former and first African president of the ICCBA, Chief Charles Taku, former First Vice President of the ICC, Madam Justice Joyce Aluoch, the former President of ICCBA David Hooper, the ASP President, Judge Silvia Fernández de Gurmendi, and former Vice-President of ICCBA, Ghislain M. Mabanga. The photo was taken on 20 July 2016 © ICC-CPI

Fatou Bensouda: The challenges and the record

June 16, 2021
Former ICC chief prosecutor Fatou Bensouda Photo credit © Ilvy Njiokiktjien / VII

The highs and lows of ICC Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda’s tenure

June 16, 2021
The International Criminal Court (ICC) states parties convene at the World Forum Convention Center in The Hague from December 5-12, 2018, for the 17th session of the Assembly of state parties Credit: The ASP Flickr account

States must take the time to choose the right ICC Prosecutor

February 11, 2021
First time in history: a vote on who becomes new ICC Prosecutor

First time in history: a vote on who becomes new ICC Prosecutor

February 10, 2021
Survivors of sexual violence that occured after the December 2007 presidential election gather at the Milimani Law Courts in Nairobi, Kenya during a hearing into a constitutional petiton they filed. The High Court is scheduled to deliver a judgment on that petition on Thursday, December 10, 2020. Credit: Physicians for Human Rights (PHR).

Kenyan SGBV victims wait with bated breath for Thursday’s judgment

December 8, 2020
Next Post

Kenya and South Africa propose supplementary agenda items for inclusion at the 14 ASP

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Login
Notify of
Please login to comment
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
No Result
View All Result

Recent Posts

  • Hope at last for Kenyan victims, but is TFV’s planned support enough?
  • Gicheru asks ICC judge to admit new evidence
  • Abd-Al-Rahman paid Janjaweed, witness tells judges
  • Gicheru opposes prosecution bid to introduce ‘fresh’ evidence
  • Khan wants Mokom to have access to Yekatom-Ngaïssona trial materials

Recent Comments

  • JFJ - Journalists for Justice on Kenyan lawyer denies bribery charges at the ICC
  • JFJ - Journalists for Justice on You did me wrong, Bemba tells ICC as he demands 70 million euros
  • JFJ - Journalists for Justice on Two victims’ lawyers in Kenyatta case in line to become next ICC prosecutor
  • JFJ - Journalists for Justice on Profiles of the four people shortlisted for the job of ICC Prosecutor
  • Write My Essay on Afghanistan case fails to take off at the ICC — pragmatism’ or surrender to the powerful?

Archives

Categories

JFJ – Journalists for Justice

We call out impunity wherever it occurs; we advocate justice for all victims of atrocity crimes; and we work with people of goodwill everywhere who share our values.

Browse by Topics:

Archives by Month:

Never Again
INTAHE
BarometreVerite
The Victims' Bantaba
No Result
View All Result
  • Confronting Impunity
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion
  • About US
  • Our Work
  • Login

Copyright © 2019. Journalists for Justice has asserted its right to be recognized as creators and owners of the content here. Reproduction in part or in whole is permitted on condition that JFJ is acknowledged and notified.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
wpDiscuz