Resources
Friday, May 27, 2022
  • Login
Journalists for Justice
No Result
View All Result

Browse by Topic:

  • Home
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Human Rights
  • Elections
  • About US
  • Our Work
  • Careers
No Result
View All Result
Journalists for Justice
  • Home
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion & Analysis
  • Human Rights
  • Elections
  • About US
  • Our Work
  • Careers
No Result
View All Result
Journalists for Justice
No Result
View All Result
Home ICC Cases

Search for the next ICC Prosecutor makes little progress

Thomas VerfussbyThomas Verfuss
December 10, 2020
in ICC Cases, ICJ
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
0
ICC Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda (right) speaks with another prosecutor on 28 August 2018 during the closing statements in the case against former Congolese rebel leader Bosco Ntaganda at the International Criminal Court in The Hague, Netherlands. Bensouda's term ends in June 2021 and the process to elect her successor is ongoing.

ICC Prosecutor Fatou Bensouda (right) speaks with another prosecutor on 28 August 2018 during the closing statements in the case against former Congolese rebel leader Bosco Ntaganda at the International Criminal Court in The Hague, Netherlands. Bensouda's term ends in June 2021 and the process to elect her successor is ongoing.

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By Thomas Verfuss in The Hague

This time states wanted to do things well. In the past the appointment processes of high international justice officials have often been criticized as opaque, interest-driven, behind-closed-doors dealing, horse-trading and an exchange of posts and favours. The selection process for the third ICC Prosecutor was meant to be exemplary: merit-based, transparent and independent.

After many months of job application procedure, the process is now often informally described by professional observers as circus, farce or tragicomedy. It is even on the record in an official document of the Bureau of the Assembly of States Parties (ASP) issued at a moment of impasse in the process where it says: “This way forward shall not be seen as a precedent for future Prosecutor elections or other Assembly processes.”

What went wrong? The Bureau of the ASP tasked a Committee on the Election of the Prosecutor (CEP), chaired by Sabine Nölke, former ambassador of Canada to The Hague, with making a pre-selection. The diplomats were assisted by a group of experts from the field, like lawyer for victims Francisco Cox.

They came up with a list that raised many eyebrows.

RelatedStories

Gicheru witness tampering trial starts before the ICC

Trial Chamber VI to hear Said Abdel Kani case

Court turns down bid to introduce elusive witness’s testimony, but allows four other statements

The “usual suspects” _ candidates with long-standing experience in the field of international criminal justice _ that all insiders had expected to be on the list were not there. In fact, the Nölke Committee had decided that it was time for “fresh blood”. Thus it deviated from the official terms of reference for the search task. The Nölke Committee added the additional criterion after informal conversations with state representatives _ without documenting how many and with which mandate.

There are situations where fresh blood can be useful for an organization, when new ideas are needed, when people have worked for many years in their daily routine in an institution without seeing its deficiencies any more. But whereas this certainly also applies to the ICC and changes are urgently needed at the dysfunctional court, according to many observers, the court now needs someone with some intimate knowledge of its inner workings to be able to quickly identify things that need to be changed at the Office of the Prosecutor (OTP), not someone who, as a newcomer, can be misled by smokescreens from the vested actors. And externally, the court needs someone with experience with international relations, used to dealing with diplomats, in order to be able to mobilise the support of states parties in the face of threats from hostile powers in Washington and Jerusalem.

In the past states have tried to [s]elect a new Prosecutor by consensus, to demonstrate joint strong support for the successful candidate. This time round, in spite of months of talks, no consensus emerged on any of the shortlisted candidates. Finally, it was decided to open up the process to the other 10 candidates who had made it to the Nölke Committee’s longlist of 14. They were asked if they were interested in rejoining the race. Five of them said yes. They are:

Carlos Castresana Fernández (Spain), Prosecutor of the Spanish Court of Auditors;

Karim A. A. Khan (United Kingdom), Special Adviser and Head of the Investigative Team to Promote Accountability for Da’esh/ISIL crimes (UNITAD);

Francesco Lo Voi (Italy), Chief District Prosecutor in Palermo, Sicily;

Robert Petit (Canada), Senior Official at the United Nations Follow-on Mechanism for the Democratic Republic of the Congo; and

Brigitte Raynaud (France), Substitut général at the prosecution of the Paris Court of Appeals.

Other candidates chose not to rejoin the race for different reasons. There was dissatisfaction about the selection process where the rules of the game were changed when the game had already started. And there were frictions and frustrations about allegations of misconduct from the MeToo movement, that were uttered, but not substantiated with concrete evidence. But still, the allegations of harassment were the talk of the town while candidates could not defend themselves because no names were officially and publicly put forward.

No consensus on who may become the third ICC Prosecutor has emerged with less than a week before the start of the ASP’s annual meeting. It starts on December 14 in The Hague and will run until December 16. It will then continue on December 17 in New York and is scheduled to conclude on December 23. Many diplomats do not expect a candidate to be elected this month. They believe a compromise candidate may be found during another session in January or February next year.

The term of the current prosecutor, Fatou Bensouda, ends in June next year.

Previous Post

Kenyan SGBV victims wait with bated breath for Thursday’s judgment

Next Post

Kenyan judge awards SGBV survivors millions of shillings in general damages

Thomas Verfuss

Thomas Verfuss

Send Email

Related Posts

Kenyan lawyer Paul Gicheru at the opening of his trial at the International Criminal Court on February 15, 2022. Photo credit: @ICC-CPI

Gicheru witness tampering trial starts before the ICC

February 16, 2022
Mr Said during the opening of the confirmation of charges hearing at the seat of the Court in The Hague (The Netherlands) on 12 October 2021 ©ICC-CPI

Trial Chamber VI to hear Said Abdel Kani case

December 20, 2021
Paul Gicheru appearing before the ICC via video-link from the ICC Detention Centre on 6 November 2020. Photo credit: ICC-CPI

Court turns down bid to introduce elusive witness’s testimony, but allows four other statements

December 17, 2021
Special Criminal Court Arrests CAR Minister Bouba for War Crimes. Photo: News Central TV

Pressure mounts for CAR minister to face justice

December 2, 2021
ICC Trial Chamber VIII declares Mr Al Mahdi guilty of the war crime of attacking historic and religious buildings in Timbuktu and sentences him to nine years' imprisonment. Photo credit: @ICC-CPI

Al Mahdi to be released early after ICC cuts sentence by two years

December 1, 2021
Dominic Ongwen's appeal hearing coming up in February 2022. Photo credit: @ICC-CPI.

Ongwen’s appeal hearing to start in February 2022

November 26, 2021
Next Post
Kenyan judge awards SGBV survivors millions of shillings in general damages

Kenyan judge awards SGBV survivors millions of shillings in general damages

0 0 votes
Article Rating
Subscribe
Login
Notify of
Please login to comment
0 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
No Result
View All Result

Recent Posts

  • Said Abdel Kani to remain in custody as Appeals Chamber rejects his plea for release
  • Are we ready? CSOs audit Kenya’s election preparedness
  • Parties prepare to wind up Gicheru case
  • Hope at last for Kenyan victims, but is TFV’s planned support enough?
  • Gicheru asks ICC judge to admit new evidence

Recent Comments

  • JFJ - Journalists for Justice on Kenyan lawyer denies bribery charges at the ICC
  • JFJ - Journalists for Justice on You did me wrong, Bemba tells ICC as he demands 70 million euros
  • JFJ - Journalists for Justice on Two victims’ lawyers in Kenyatta case in line to become next ICC prosecutor
  • JFJ - Journalists for Justice on Profiles of the four people shortlisted for the job of ICC Prosecutor
  • Write My Essay on Afghanistan case fails to take off at the ICC — pragmatism’ or surrender to the powerful?

Archives

Categories

JFJ – Journalists for Justice

We call out impunity wherever it occurs; we advocate justice for all victims of atrocity crimes; and we work with people of goodwill everywhere who share our values.

Browse by Topics:

Archives by Month:

Never Again
INTAHE
BarometreVerite
The Victims' Bantaba
No Result
View All Result
  • Confronting Impunity
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion
  • About US
  • Our Work
  • Login

Copyright © 2019. Journalists for Justice has asserted its right to be recognized as creators and owners of the content here. Reproduction in part or in whole is permitted on condition that JFJ is acknowledged and notified.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
wpDiscuz