Resources
Sunday, February 28, 2021
Journalists for Justice
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Confronting Impunity
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion
  • About US
  • Our Work
No Result
View All Result
Journalists for Justice
  • Home
  • Confronting Impunity
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion
  • About US
  • Our Work
No Result
View All Result
Journalists for Justice
No Result
View All Result
Home ASP

First time in history: a vote on who becomes new ICC Prosecutor

Thomas Verfuss by Thomas Verfuss
February 10, 2021
in ASP, Commentary, Headline, Opinion and Analysis, Top Story
4 min read
0
First time in history: a vote on who becomes new ICC Prosecutor

Assembly of state parties 2020

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

By Thomas Verfuss in The Hague

For the first time in history there will be a vote on Friday on who should become the new chief prosecutor of the International Criminal Court (ICC). No consensus could be reached to appoint Fatou Bensouda’s successor by acclamation, in spite of months of strenuous efforts of the presidency of the ASP, the assembly of the 123 states that are parties to the Rome Statute, the founding treaty of the ICC.

RelatedPosts

Khan’s supporters welcome his election, but his critics still wary due to his role in Kenya case

States must take the time to choose the right ICC Prosecutor

States split between Karim Khan and Fergal Gaynor for ICC Prosecutor

Four states have nominated candidates for the voting procedure scheduled to start at 10 am (New York time) at UN Headquarters. The choice will be among Karim Khan (UK), Fergal Gaynor (Ireland), Carlos Castresana (Spain) and Francesco Lo Voi (Italy). It is not clear yet how many rounds of voting will be needed for one candidate to obtain the required majority of 62 states.

ASP president Kwon O-Gon tried to build consensus around Khan after he had emerged as front runner during informal “opinion polls” among the 123 member states. But, as one ambassador puts it, you can’t build consensus if some countries let their objections become vetoes – no consensus without compromise. Then Spain gave the final blow to the consensus building process when it decided to nominate Castresana.

Khan is widely credited for his experience, intellectual mindset, legal and trial skills and integrity. But the problem is that he has been deeply involved on the defence side with situations he would have to deal with as ICC Prosecutor: he represented vice-president William Ruto of Kenya and Saif Al-Islam Gaddafi, son of the murdered leader of Libya. Khan says that he would recuse himself from these “situation countries” as a matter of integrity, but these assurances seem not to be enough for some states.

Others point to his current position as assistant secretary-general of the United Nations who leads a war crimes investigation in Iraq into crimes committed by Da’esh/ISIL. One must be close to the British and American governments to obtain that post, some say, governments whose men Khan might have to investigate as ICC Prosecutor.

Gaynor was second in the informal “opinion polls”. Some diplomats suggested that consensus should be built around him. But then others said that he has never led a big organization like the Office of the Prosecutor (OTP) and not regularly rubbed shoulders with government ministers like other chief prosecutors of international courts before him. The ICC Prosecutor must not only organize investigations and prosecutions – [s]he also is an international diplomat in the constant search for support from states, be it to obtain arrests of the fugitives or to find the money to run the organization in the first place.

Castresana was clearly in the last of the three positions in the unofficial soundings among states. Lo Voi was not included at all in the last round. But experienced insiders point out that the dynamics of a secret ballot are completely different from those of diplomatic consensus building. So it is impossible to predict what will happen on Friday – or as of Friday, as the voting process may take time and may be interrupted to convince one or more countries to retract their hapless candidates.

The Rome Statute and the rules of procedure of the ASP don’t say what must happen after several inconclusive rounds of voting. But the matter was dealt with in various resolutions in the early years after the entry into force of the Rome Statute, one veteran diplomat recalls. There should be a break for consultations after three inconclusive rounds of voting. Then, if there is still no new Prosecutor after the fourth round, there should be a fifth one between the two strongest candidates only.

Some point to the end of Bensouda’s tenure in June – but one ambassador says the court can do for a while without chief prosecutor as it has a deputy prosecutor, and the community of states should take the time to find the best candidate. 

The first two ICC Prosecutors, Luis Moreno Ocampo and Fatou Bensouda, were appointed by consensus after lots of horse-trading behind the scenes. This time states led by Kwon wanted to do things better and let independent experts do a pre-selection, next to a committee of diplomats. The process started to derail last year when the Committee on the Election of the prosecutor submitted a shortlist of four to the ASP Bureau. Many eyebrows were raised because heavyweights that everybody expected to be on the list, like Khan and Serge Brammertz, were missing. The list was then expanded, but no compromise found. Now it is up to individual states parties to propose their candidates and obtain a majority.

Previous Post

States split between Karim Khan and Fergal Gaynor for ICC Prosecutor

Next Post

States must take the time to choose the right ICC Prosecutor

Related Posts

The newly elected ICC Prosecutor Karim Khan

Khan’s supporters welcome his election, but his critics still wary due to his role in Kenya case

by Millicent Zighe
February 22, 2021

...

The International Criminal Court (ICC) states parties convene at the World Forum Convention Center in The Hague from December 5-12, 2018, for the 17th session of the Assembly of state parties Credit: The ASP Flickr account

States must take the time to choose the right ICC Prosecutor

by Journalists For Justice
February 11, 2021

...

African NGOs strongly advise for or against Khan as new ICC chief prosecutor

States split between Karim Khan and Fergal Gaynor for ICC Prosecutor

by Millicent Zighe
February 7, 2021

...

Kenyan Lawyer, Paul Gicheru makes first appearance before the ICC

Paul Gicheru gives exclusive interview to Kenyan newspaper

by Susan Kendi
February 7, 2021

...

123 states in search of new prosecutor

123 states in search of new prosecutor

by Thomas Verfuss
February 5, 2021

...

Carlos Castresana outlines his vision for the ICC

Carlos Castresana outlines his vision for the ICC

by Millicent Zighe
February 5, 2021

...

Next Post
The International Criminal Court (ICC) states parties convene at the World Forum Convention Center in The Hague from December 5-12, 2018, for the 17th session of the Assembly of state parties Credit: The ASP Flickr account

States must take the time to choose the right ICC Prosecutor

Leave a Reply

Please Login to comment
Connect with
I allow to create an account
When you login first time using a Social Login button, we collect your account public profile information shared by Social Login provider, based on your privacy settings. We also get your email address to automatically create an account for you in our website. Once your account is created, you'll be logged-in to this account.
DisagreeAgree
  Subscribe  
Notify of

FollowJFJustice

JFJ – Journalists for Justice

We call out impunity and raise victim voices to demand accountability for atrocity crimes wherever they occur.

Follow Us

Archives

Our Microsites

Never Again
INTAHE
BarometreVerite
The Point
No Result
View All Result
  • Confronting Impunity
  • Communities of Justice
  • Opinion
  • About US
  • Our Work

Copyright © 2019. Journalists for Justice has asserted its right to be recognized as creators and owners of the content here. Reproduction in part or in whole is permitted on condition that JFJ is acknowledged and notified.

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Fill the forms bellow to register

All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
wpDiscuz